The Pearl Files: Awkward debate highlighted divisive online spaces

Is Pearl’s Advice on “Pick Me” Behavior Really a Solution? Bless her heart. Pearl is back with another take on relationships, and this time it revolves around Anna Kasparian and, essentially, how women should behave to avoid being perceived as a “pick me.” Now, I understand the core message – that authenticity is important and trying too hard to appeal to a certain group, especially by denigrating other women, isn’t a good look. But, honey, life, love, and relationships are far more nuanced than a simple “don’t be a pick me” prescription. Let’s gently unpack this a little, shall we? Pearl’s argument, as I understand it, seems to suggest that women should avoid expressing opinions that might align with traditionally masculine viewpoints in an attempt to gain male validation. The implication is that women who do so are somehow inauthentic and are sacrificing their own values for attention. On the surface, it’s a call for women to be true to themselves. And Lord knows, I’m all about being true to yourself! However, this advice overlooks a few crucial realities. Firstly, it assumes that everyone has a perfectly formed, unwavering set of opinions that are entirely independent of outside influence. The truth is, our beliefs are constantly evolving as we encounter new information and perspectives. To penalize a woman for potentially agreeing with a viewpoint, regardless of who typically holds it, seems a little bit unfair, doesn’t it? Secondly, it perpetuates a rather tired narrative that suggests women are inherently in competition with each other for male attention. While competition can exist (and sometimes is even encouraged by societal pressures), it’s not the defining characteristic of all female interactions. Women can, and very often do, have genuine, supportive friendships and relationships that have nothing to do with vying for male approval. Framing it this way pits women against each other and misses the entire idea that some women genuinely believe in the points they are making. Thirdly, the “pick me” label is often weaponized to silence women who express opinions that are deemed unpopular or that challenge the status quo. Think about it: a woman expresses a conservative viewpoint? “Pick me!” A woman agrees with a man’s assessment of a situation? “Pick me!” It’s a convenient way to dismiss a woman’s thoughts without actually engaging with the content of what she’s saying. It becomes a shaming tactic, making women hesitant to voice their true opinions for fear of being ridiculed. Furthermore, Pearl’s advice seems to assume that the ultimate goal is to attract a partner. While finding a compatible partner is a desire for many, it’s certainly not the only measure of a woman’s worth or success. Encouraging women to tailor their personalities and opinions to appeal to potential partners, even if subconsciously, can lead to a loss of self and a sense of inauthenticity, the very thing Pearl is trying to avoid. True and lasting relationships are built on mutual respect and understanding, not on pretending to be someone you’re not. Now, I’m not saying that there aren’t women who genuinely engage in attention-seeking behavior by putting down other women. Of course, there are. But the solution isn’t to universally caution women against expressing certain opinions. The solution is to foster a culture of critical thinking, open dialogue, and mutual respect. Encourage women to examine their own biases, to challenge their own assumptions, and to be confident in expressing their authentic selves, regardless of whether those selves align with traditionally masculine or feminine viewpoints. The key, my dears, is self-awareness and understanding the motivation behind your words and actions. Are you genuinely passionate about a particular viewpoint, or are you seeking external validation? Are you trying to elevate yourself by tearing others down? These are the questions we should be asking ourselves, rather than simply avoiding any opinion that might be perceived as “unfeminine.” Ultimately, I believe that the most valuable advice we can give young women is to cultivate self-confidence, critical thinking skills, and a strong sense of self-worth. Encourage them to form their own opinions based on careful consideration and to express those opinions with clarity and respect. And remind them that their worth is not determined by their ability to attract a partner or by their adherence to any arbitrary set of gender norms. So, while Pearl’s intentions are likely good, her advice is a little simplistic and could potentially do more harm than good. Life is messy, relationships are complicated, and being true to yourself is an ongoing journey, not a destination. Just be your best self and have a good heart, and you will be fine.

---

Learn more about Pulse of Fame and our editorial team. Want to weigh in? Join the conversation in the Pulse of Fame community forum.

Related: The Pearl Files: JustPearlyThings debate: Feminism wins big.